« 12 CIOs Who Love Social Media | Main | Step Away From The Computer »

Saying Why Is A Powerful Tool Wed 01 Jul 09

Adding An Explanation For Our Policies Can Improve Their Effectiveness

Ten commandments robeena Most IT policies are written like the Ten Commandments.  Thou Shalt Not…  Thou Shalt Not…  Thou Shalt Not…  When you read them you almost expect them to be accompanied by a roll of thunder and a flash of lightning as the rules are laid down by the IT god.

Sometimes a more enlightened IT department will write policies in a more positive fashion.  Instead of Thou Shalt Not… they write it as Thou Shall… 

But with both approaches there is still something fundamentally missing.  What's missing is the explanation of why.  People want to know why they can't do something and are more likely to comply if they understand the reason for the restriction.

While God may be able to put forth the Ten Commandments without explanation, IT, despite our own sense of self-importance, cannot and still expect full compliance.  Mark Graban recently posted an interesting piece on the Lean Blog, The Power of Explaining Why - A Funny Example that highlights the power of including a simple explanation.

Explaining why treats people like adults.  People will react in the same way that you treat them.  If you treat them like adults, they'll act like adults.  You treat them like children, they'll act like children.  Adults, once they understand the reasoning in the policy will comply with both the letter and, more importantly, the spirit of the policy.

Complying with the spirit of the policy is important.  I once had a boss that talked about draconian policies and how they fostered what he called "malicious obedience".  As he explained all that it takes to bring things to a screeching halt if for everyone to follow our 'perfect' policies, perfectly.  People doing nothing more than the minimum to comply with the policy is counter-productive to what we are trying to accomplish.

I think people are sometime reluctant to explain why as it might imply the topic is open for discussion or negotiation.  It really doesn't.  Saying that employees are not permitted to disable or shutdown anti-virus programs on their PCs because it opens their PC and the entire network to the possibility of a dangerous virus infection does not mean that it is optional or that deliberate non-compliance won't result in disciplinary action.

More significantly, we may be reluctant to give explanations because user may question the validity of that explanation.  However, if there truly is a valid reason than justifying the explanation is easy and there shouldn't be a problem. 

The difficulty comes when the underlying reason is questionable or self-serving.  If for example, IT sets a policy because it makes IT's life easier at the expense of the users it may rightly be open to debate (at the appropriate levels of course).  However, once the appropriate people have reviewed it and agreed we should have no problem saying it is being done for that reason.

It's actually very simple.  If you don't feel comfortable with the explanation for a policy it probably isn't a valid reason.  If it is a good justification then there is no reason not to share it with everyone.  After all it's really not that hard to include a statement of explanation so why not do it?

Explaining why also has another added benefit - documentation.  Policies have a bad habit of becoming eternal, once put in place it is hard to remove them.  The reason for this is the underlying assumption that there just must be a good reason for the policy.  The problem is that over time the good reason is forgotten and may no longer be valid.  By adding the explanation we are also documenting it and it can easily highlight when a policy should be modified or made obsolete.

Make no mistake, explaining why will not guarantee full acceptance or compliance of IT policies.  There will always be issues but telling people why may significantly improve the situation.  If you can improve the effectiveness of your policies by including the explanation of why it certainly makes sense to do so.

"Ten Commandments" photo by robeeena

If this topic was of interest, you might also like these:

            Tell A Friend Tell a Friend    View blog reactions   Bookmark    rss RSS Feed


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Saying Why Is A Powerful Tool:



tell_a_friend Tell a Friend About Mike's Blog

Creative Commons License 
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.5 License.

My photos on
Mike Schaffner's items Go to Mike Schaffner's photostream

Free Subscriptions
  Free RSS Subscription

Free RSS Subscription

For An Email Of New Articles
Enter your email address:

Read On Your Mobile Device


Join the Conversation
Subscribe to Comments
  Free RSS Subscription

For New Comments Email
Enter your email address:

This is the personal blog of Michael W. Schaffner. The opinions expressed in this blog are soley mine and those of commenters. You should not infer that these opinions are the opinion of or have been endorsed by any current or former employer.

Please review the Privacy Policy.   I do love comments and trackbacks but I do reserve the right to remove any that don't comply with the Comments and Trackback Policy.  Rather than clutter up the front page with badges and statistics that are of little interest to anyone other than me I thought it would be best to establish a separate page for statistics and rankings.

Copyright © 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009 Michael W. Schaffner       You may copy or quote sections of this blog if you provide an attribution consisting of a reference to the Michael Schaffner and ''Beyond Blinking Lights and Acronyms" along with a hyperlink (if a web reference) to the blog posting.     

Creative Commons License 
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.5 License.